Keeper’s Pie

keeper’s pie

I came across a recipe for Keeper’s Pie recently – the pie is made with pheasant and venison, in the manner of Cottage or Shepherd’s Pie, with mashed potatoes and cheese on top – something that’s right up my street! I’d never heard of Keeper’s Pie before, but when I looked there are a few variations out there – this is my take on the dish.

venison mince

I went straight to the game stall on Sunday, for the usual brace of pheasants and a pack of venison mince. Farmed venison meat is available throughout the year – the deer are kept in large open spaces and for the most part allowed to do as they please. All game has less fat than farmed meat and considerably more flavour. Venison in particular, is the kind of food hunter gatherers would have eaten millions of years ago.

browned pheasant

I made my own pheasant stock, but chicken stock would make a good alternative. Using a cast iron casserole, brown a pheasant in olive oil, to caramelise the sugars in the meat and skin. When the pheasant is a nice golden colour, remove the olive oil and save for later.

stock vegetables

Pheasant Stock recipe:

1 pheasant
6 pieces garlic (peeled and bruised)
1 large carrot
1 stick of celery
a bouquet garni of 2 bay leaves and a sprig or two of rosemary, sage and thyme
10 black peppercorns
6 crushed juniper berries
olive oil
sea salt (4 or 5 turns)
2 pints water

Fill the pot with the stock ingredients listed above.


Bring to a simmer, skim off any scum, put the lid on and remove to a preheated oven at 150º C for 1 hour. Turn the bird half way through. When done, remove the pheasant and allow to cool. Strain the stock and throw away the depleted vegetables. When the bird has cooled, remove the meat from the skin and bones. Chop the pheasant up into bite sized pieces. This pheasant was quite big (1.25 Kg), so I used half the meat for the pie and saved the rest for a rainy day.

Keeper’s Pie recipe (serves 4):

350g minced venison
1/2 the meat of the previously poached pheasant chopped into bite sized pieces
1 large onion (chopped)
6 cloves garlic (finely chopped)
1 large carrot (chopped)
1 large stick of celery (chopped)
8 medium mushrooms (chopped)
1 heaped dessertspoon plain four
1 glass red wine
a splash or two red wine vinegar (to taste)
a splash mushroom ketchup
2 large squirts anchovy paste
a dessertspoon tomato purée
1 beef stock cube
1 pint pheasant, game or chicken stock
2 bay leaves
cracked black pepper (to taste)
the olive oil from browning the pheasant
a knob of goose fat


Poach the chopped onion in a knob of goose fat and the leftover olive oil.

venison browning

When the onion looks soft stir in the venison mince and turn the heat up to brown it.


When the meat has taken some colour, stir in the carrot, celery and garlic – add the mushrooms after a few minutes.

pheasant meat

When the mushrooms look shiny, mix in the chopped pheasant.


Follow the bird with anchovy paste, tomato purée and a dessertspoon plain flour. Stir to create a roux.


Pour on the red wine, vinegar and stock to make a rich sauce. Sprinkle on the black pepper and add the bay leaves. Turn the heat up, stir and taste. A little splash of mushroom ketchup and half a beef stock cube will bring out the umami (savoury) in the sauce. Add the rest of the beef cube later (if you feel it’s necessary). You will notice that I only added half my pheasant stock – the pie filling should be reasonably thick, but it’s good to have a little extra stock on hand just in case it gets too dry.


Put a lid on the casserole and remove to a preheated oven at 160º C for 1 1/2 – 2 hours – stir occasionally. I left the lid off for the last 30 minutes to enhance the viscosity.

pie filling

Check the seasoning and allow the pie filling to cool – it will lose heat more quickly if spread out into the cold pie dish.

In the meantime, make some mashed or riced potatoes. I used a potato ricer, which gets rid of all the lumps, but plain mash would be fine.

Riced potatoes:

8 medium red potatoes (peeled and cut in half)
3 knobs of butter
sea salt and cracked black pepper (to taste)
200g grated cheddar
a splash or two of cream or milk

riced potato

Rice or mash the potatoes with butter, salt, pepper, milk (or cream) to taste. Spread the potato out on top of the now cooled pie filling. Get out the ox and plough (fork) to make nice neat furrows in the potato – or create peaks if you prefer.


Grate some cheese of your choosing (mine was mature English cheddar) onto the potato.

keeper’s pie

Bake in a hot oven at 200º C for 30 – 45 minutes, until golden. Allow the pie to rest for 10 minutes before serving with seasonal vegetables, e.g. Brussels sprouts and cauliflower. Drink a robust red wine with the Keeper’s Pie, such as Heredad Mestral crianza a Priorat from Catalunya.

I love the smell of toasty cheese and potatoes – it’s wonderfully earthy and reminds me of cooking jacket potatoes on a bonfire in the cub scouts many moons ago. Combine that cheese and potatoes with game and you have a sensational supper!

Other pheasant posts
Other venison posts

About Mad Dog
This entry was posted in Drink, Fish, Food, Game, Meat, Recipes and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Keeper’s Pie

  1. Eha says:

    Hmph ! Unfair, Mad – to most of us !! So how many of us reading can even dream of holding ‘a packet of ‘wild venison extra lean mince’ in our hands ? Not that I would not love it . . . or have the pheasant in hand to make the delicious stock ‘your way’ ! You know I would be perchance just diplomatic should I state cottage pie was my favourute ‘comfort’ food . . . but was I able to access what you can methinks this would make a delightful delicious meal . . . be well . . .

  2. Karen says:

    I’d never heard of Keeper’s Pie before but I like everything about the dish…perfect to warm you up as well as put a smile on your face.

  3. Ron says:

    Hello Mad Dog, it’s very good to be back reading your blog today. I think Keepers pie is a keeper indeed. Halleluja, a recipe I can eat, although a few subs might be necessary to maintain my daily fat intake. As much as I love the stuff, the goose fat will not be there. Cheese in moderation, but the rest plays well for me. We have moose mince in the freezer which is extremely lean which should work for this, but the pheasant might be problematic. I know it’s wonderful in the dish, but perhaps I should go with chicken or turkey breast.

    • Mad Dog says:

      Thanks Ron – it’s good to see you back! I’m glad you like the pie – I’m sure chicken or turkey will work, or perhaps pigeon or guinea fowl.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.